Selves and Others
Archived page > 6 October 2004

Selves and Others

Wednesday, October 6, 2004
Pacific News Service
Iraq War Should Not Be a Video Game
by Pedro Paulo Viegas De Sa

Editor’s Note: A new video game that uses real-life footage from contemporary battles in Iraq exploits the sacrifices of U.S. soldiers, the writer says.

Halliburton is not the only company that seeks to profit from the war in Iraq. Video game makers do, too. Kuma Reality Games’ "Kuma War — The War On Terror," which was previously only available online, will be released into stores in October. (...)

ZNet
Iraq’s Oil
by Youssef M. Ibrahim

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates, October 6, 2004 - The costs and benefits of America’s occupation of Iraq vary, according to proponents and opponents, except when it comes to oil exports. The U.S.-led invasion has resulted in the loss of an average of 2 million barrels a day of Iraqi oil from world markets. That is a significant number with huge consequences for economies around the globe. Instead of rosy promises by the neoconservatives of the Bush administration who pushed for the invasion - partly on the premise that they would turn it into America’s private gasoline-pumping station - the contrary has occurred. (...)

Inter Press Service
Bush’s Case for War Crumbles
by Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Oct 6 (IPS) - Is there anything at all left of the Bush administration’s case for going to war in Iraq or, for that matter, the way it has been fought?

The answer seems increasingly doubtful given what appears to be an accelerating cascade of news, leaks and admissions by senior administration officials over the past several weeks. (...)

Inter Press Service
U.N. Unions Want Workers Out of Iraq
by Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Oct 6 (IPS) - Nation-wide elections in Iraq, scheduled to take place before the end of January 2005, are now jeopardised by two powerful U.N. staff unions demanding that no U.N. employees be sent to the violence-ridden country. (...)

Z Magazine
Iran’s Dire Threat
It might be able to defend itself
by Edward S. Herman

Fog Watch

So just as Guatemala, Nicaragua, and Iraq were dire threats, so is Iran today because the Bush government says so and is supported here by Ariel Sharon. The first rule in supportive propaganda is to intensify attention to the villain and the alleged threat that he poses.... The second rule in supportive propaganda is to frame the issues in such a way that the premises of the propaganda source are taken as given, with any inconvenient considerations ignored and any sources that would contest the party line bypassed or marginalized.

[October 2004, Volume 17, Number 10]

CounterPunch
Rethinking Weapons of Mass Destruction
Deterring Empire
by Mike Whitney

Conventional wisdom informs us that "weapons of mass murder" in the hands of terrorists is the greatest danger facing the world today. Regrettably, people from both sides of the political aisle accept this pronouncement as though it was a fundamental law of physics. Leftists are just as apt to advocate ratcheting up surveillance, increasing covert operations and circumventing the law to make sure that, as Bush says, "the world’s most dangerous weapons don’t get into the hands of the world’s most dangerous people." (...)

CounterPunch
"Please, Dude, Can I Take Them Out?"
Targeting Civilians in Fallujah
by Jeffrey St. Clair

Last April, an F-16 fighter jet cruising over Fallujah, the stronghold of the Iraqi insurgency, zeroed in on a crowd of people mulling about on a street corner in the heart of the city. The American pilot of the fighter radioed back to his mission commander asking for permission to "take them out." (...)

The Observer
US ’hyping’ Darfur genocide fears
by Peter Beaumont

American warnings that Darfur is heading for an apocalyptic humanitarian catastrophe have been widely exaggerated by administration officials, it is alleged by international aid workers in Sudan. Washington’s desire for a regime change in Khartoum has biased their reports, it is claimed. (...) [Sun October 3, 2004 | page 2]

ZNet
Beheading the UN
by Satya Sagar

In every standard Bollywood movie there comes a scene that never fails to work up the audience into a frenzy of excitement and applause. The hero, after being whipped black and blue by the villain and his henchmen, finally wipes the blood off his chin and starts kicking ass like he invented the concept. (...)

DAWN
The Budget and Poverty Alleviation in Pakistan
by Humeira Iqtidar

The newly announced budget in Pakistan relies heavily on the World Bank and IMF’s preferred mode of poverty reduction, liberalization that is supposed to generate investment, preferably foreign, leading to employment, eventually culminating in reduced poverty. That at least is the theory. In practice there have been severe problems with this strategy. However, the Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers espousing this strategy have been sponsored by the World Bank and other donors and are celebrated as being participatory, and dynamic; a ‘living document’ evolving with the needs of the people. The Pakistani PRSP has been recently finalized, in December 2003 and has a profound impact on the recently proposed budget. (...)

CounterPunch
Canadian Firms Soaked in Iraqi and Afghan Blood
Abstaining Only in Concept from War
by Matthew Behrens

While Paul Martin was congratulating Canada on "not participating" in the U.S.-led invasion and occupation of Iraq during last spring’s federal election, a Quebec-based weapons firm sealed a deal which will ensure that every time Iraqi or Afghani blood is shed, a Canadian-made bullet will be one of the prime suspects. (...)

Ha’aretz
What would Israel do without UNRWA?
by Amira Hass

Peter Hansen, the commissioner-general of the UN Relief and Works Agency in the territories, is being persecuted for having spoken the truth: Members of Hamas work in UNRWA. The Canadian Foreign Affairs Department is concerned and the Israeli Foreign Ministry is upset over the "revelation." Two days after the broadcast of aerial photos that allegedly show, according to Israel, Palestinians loading a Qassam rocket into a UNRWA ambulance, Hansen’s words could strengthen Israeli accusations that "UNRWA is collaborating with terrorists." (...)

Democracy Now!
Cheney, Edwards Clash Over Iraq and Justification for War in Vice Presidential Debate
by Rahul Mahajan, Robert Parry

Vice Presidential nominees Dick Cheney and John Edwards faced off in the first and only vice presidential debate of the election Tuesday night. We hear excerpts of the nominees discussing Iraq, the White House linking 9/11 to Saddam Hussein and more and get analysis from journalists Rahul Mahajan and Robert Parry.

CounterPunch
Cheney’s Poison Lab
Wrong Town, Wrong Target
by Kevin McKiernan

By way of implying that Saddam Hussein and Al Qaeda were connected, Dick Cheney claimed that a poisons lab existed before the war in Iraq in a town called Khurmal.

The vice president didn’t say so, but Khurmal is in northern Iraq, an area that was controlled by the Kurds, not the former Iraqi regime. (...)

Democracy Now!
Cheney Cites El Salvador Civil War That Killed 75,000 As Model for Afghanistan
by Rahul Mahajan, Robert Parry

When asked about the situation in Afghanistan and the upcoming election, Vice President Dick Cheney called it a success in democracy and compared it to El Salvador in the 1980s. We speak with veteran investigative journalist Robert Parry about what he calls the "bloody mess" of El Salvador and Rahul Mahajan about voter manipulation in Afghanistan.

Democracy Now!
Edwards Attacks Cheney On Halliburton Dealings in Iran, Bribing Foreign Officials and No-Bid Contract in Iraq
by John Nichols

At the Vice Presidential debate, John Edwards dropped what pundits are calling the "H-Bomb" on Dick Cheney - Halliburton. We speak with John Nichols of The Nation magazine and author of Dick: The Man Who Is President about Halliburton’s record while Cheney was its CEO and beyond.

Democracy Now!
A Look at How Cheney Opposed Head Start, MLK Day, and the Release of Mandela
by John Nichols

John Edwards blasted Dick Cheney’s voting record as a congressman where he voted against the release of Nelson Mandela, instituting a holiday for Martin Luther King, Jr., Head Start and more. We speak with John Nichols of The Nation magazine and author of Dick: The Man Who Is President.

CounterPunch
More of the Same: Israel Wins the Debates
by Tarif Abboushi

John Kerry and John Edwards used their debates with George W. Bush and Dick Cheney to tell America that if the incumbents are re-elected, as far as Iraq goes we can expect ’More of the same.’ Those four words exemplify the essence of the Democrats’ argument for regime change in the U.S., a Kerry-Edwards mantra, if you will, that defines the Bush administration’s plan for dealing with the debacle they got us into in Iraq. But there’s another mantra that bodes equally ill for our efforts to win the peace in Iraq, one that is used by Democrats and Republicans alike to encapsulate their approach to dealing with the mother of all issues in the region: ’Israel has a right to defend itself.’ (...)

Political Affairs
John Edwards vs. Darth Vader
by Joel Wendland

When Dick Cheney confessed to Gwen Ifill of PBS, the moderator of last night’s vice presidential debate, that he did not know anything about the struggles faced by African American women with AIDS, his admission spoke directly to one of the defining characteristics of the Bush administration: the decided lack of interest in or concern for the difficulties faced by the most oppressed, most troubled sections of the US population. During this 90-minute debate, Senator John Edwards produced a solid presentation that highlighted the glaring difference between the Bush administration and the leadership Americans expect in a president. (...)

AP
US vetoes resolution calling for Israeli halt to Gaza operations
by Gerald Nadler

The United States vetoed an Arab-backed UN Security Council resolution calling for a halt to Israeli military operations in Gaza.

Last night’s vote in the 15-member Security Council was 11 in favour, one against, and three abstentions by Britain, Germany and Romania. (...)

TomDispatch
The Opiate of the Electorate
by Michael Schwartz

If your anti-Bush sentiments have turned into electoral passion, then you probably restrained your exhilaration after last Thursday’s debate until you got a sense of how it played to the American electorate; which means, how it played in the polls that began to pour out only moments after the event ended. The first "instant" polls seemed to indicate a Kerry victory, and by Sunday the Newsweek poll (considered notoriously unreliable by the pros) had appeared with the news that Kerry had pulled even or might be ahead in the presidential sweepstakes. If it was then that the real rush of excitement hit you, face it, like a host of other Americans, you’re a polls addict. (...)

Media Lens
Quick Response to Blair’s Speech
by David Cromwell

Tony Blair’s speech yesterday to the Labour Party Conference in Brighton was "low-key, conversational and reasoned" the Guardian informs us (Leader, September 29, 2004). And his "long-awaited apology on Iraq, as far as it went, was a rightly well-received milestone in his fragile rehabilitation with his critics".

How nice. No matter that Blair lied about intelligence on WMD, ignored security warnings about unleashing more terrorist attacks, and deceived Parliament and the country over the nonsensical "serious and current threat" posed by a strangled Third World nation. (...)

Green Left Weekly
Why Washington won’t save Darfur villagers
by Norm Dixon

On September 21, Salih Booker, the director of the Africa Studies Program at the Washington-based Council on Foreign Relations ruling-class think tank, argued in the International Herald Tribune that the US government has failed to convince the UN Security Council to take tough action to end Sudan’s “government-sponsored campaign of genocide” in Darfur because it “cried wolf” over Saddam Hussein’s non-existent weapons of mass destruction in order to justify its illegal invasion of Iraq.

Booker and many other US liberals, as well as influential establishment organisations such as Human Rights Watch and the International Crisis Group (ICG), are campaigning for President George Bush to launch a military “humanitarian intervention” in western Darfur. (...)

The Independent
Life and death in Darfur
Separated from her family and her home destroyed, Halima is just one of the thousands of elderly victims of the nightmare that has ravaged Sudan. She talks to Kate Holt and Sarah Hughes
by Kate Holt, Sarah Hughes

Halima is in her sixties. She was born in the village of Hajr Shalick, east of El Geneina in West Darfur, and has lived in the Kerenic Camp, a settlement for internally displaced people near El Geneina, for the past year

" I came to this camp nearly a year ago with my grandson Ismail, who is only five years old, and my daughter Fatima, his mother. We walked all the way, carrying my grandson in our arms. We had nothing. The Arab militias had stolen everything we owned. We had 12 cows, 50 goats and sheep, four donkeys - they took them all. (...)

AP
US running mates clash over Iraq
by Tom Raum

The two vice-presidential candidates in next month’s US elections clashed over Iraq in their televised campaign debate.

The Republican candidate Dick Cheney accused Democratics of turning against the war for political gain. (...)

The Guardian
My first night in Guantánamo
It took a very special play to turn Desmond Tutu into an actor. He tells Simon Hattenstone about the role he could not refuse
by Simon Hattenstone

Desmond Tutu is taking his off-Broadway debut in his stride. "I’m just waiting for my Tony nominations now," he says from his New York hotel. Tutu, 72, is relaxing for a few minutes after two well-received performances in Guantánamo: Honour Bound to Defend Freedom. Then he is on his way to Rochester, Chicago, Philadelphia and back home. (...) [page 10 | G2 features]

The Guardian
Tigris Tales
I am in a police convoy speeding south of Baghdad. Then the young officer in charge gives an order that shocks us all
by Ghaith Abdul-Ahad

For the first time in more than 35 years Iraqis are free to talk, discuss and debate - publicly and relatively without fear - the political and social aspects of their daily life. But for most of them all they can talk about is violence.

What happened this morning? How many mortars fell on your neighbourhood yesterday? Did the Americans free your cousins or are they still being "interrogated"? All these questions have become part of the daily chit-chat of Iraqis when they meet in the souq, bus or cafe. (...) [page 7 | G2 features]

The Guardian
Bush is dead wrong
by Joseph Stiglitz

Many around the world are surprised at how little attention the economy is receiving in President Bush’s re-election campaign. But I am not surprised: if I were Bush, the last thing I would want to talk about is the economy. Yet many people look at America’s economy, even over these past three-and-a-half years, with some envy. Annual economic growth - at an average rate of 2.5% - may have been markedly slower than during the Clinton years, but it still looks strong compared with Europe’s anaemic 1%. (...) [page 23 | Comment]

Project Syndicate

The Guardian
Rumsfeld’s missing link

Iraq and 9/11

Donald Rumsfeld was at his laconic best at a New York thinktank on Monday when he said there was no "strong, hard evidence" linking al-Qaida to Iraq. But the statement still dropped like a bombshell. This was not one of the defence secretary’s famous "unknown unknowns", but a clear known, albeit unconvincingly qualified yesterday by the claim that he had been "regrettably misunderstood". Mr Rumsfeld is thankfully on his way out of the Pentagon, retiring after next month’s presidential elections, whether or not George Bush beats John Kerry. But if his own career is ending, others, including Mr Bush, are likely to - and certainly should - suffer significant collateral damage from his admission. (...) [page 25 | Comment]

The Guardian
Bribery begins at home
If Africa is to overcome corruption the west will have to clean up its own act
by Andrew Phillips, Susan Hawley

Next year, Britain is planning to make Africa the centre-piece of its presidencies of the European Union and the G8 industrialised nations. Tony Blair’s Commission for Africa, which opens its second meeting in Ethiopia tomorrow to discuss how the international community can help build a "strong and prosperous Africa", will be central to that effort. However, the UK government is potentially facing a serious credibility problem on Africa that could undermine its efforts to heal what Blair calls "the scar on the conscience of the world". (...) [page 24 | Comment]

The Guardian
Pastor Bush
Why do so many Americans dismiss the evidence that the occupation of Iraq has gone disastrously wrong? Because the US has a long tradition of putting faith before facts. Jonathan Raban on George Bush’s debt to the Puritans
by Jonathan Raban

In the secular, liberal, top-left-hand corner of the US where I live, the prevailing mood was one not far short of despair as incredulity mounted that the daily avalanche of bad news from Baghdad, Fallujah, Tikrit, Samarra, Najaf, Nasiriyah, Kufa, Ramadi, Baquba and elsewhere was apparently failing to make any significant dent in Bush’s poll numbers, or expose his claim that freedom and democracy are on the march in Iraq as a blithe and cynical fiction. (...) [pages 8 - 9 | G2 features]

The Independent
Iraq Survey Group to concede defeat in search for WMD
by Rupert Cornwell

The Iraq Survey Group is expected to report today that it has found no evidence of chemical, biological or nuclear weapons in post-war Iraq.

Charles Duelfer, the chief UN arms inspector in Iraq, is due to present the findings in a 1,500-page report to Congress. (...)

The Independent
Rumsfeld, Bremer and WMD inspectors cast shadow on war
by Rupert Cornwell

President George Bush’s rationale for the Iraq war, and his subsequent handling of the conflict, have been separately undermined by two of his own top officials ­ handing precious new ammunition to the Democrats as the election campaign enters a crucial phase. (...)

The Independent
’When they heard the explosion, the Israelis went crazy. They were shooting everywhere’
by Donald Macintyre

in Jabaliya refugee camp

The message that had been blaring through the loudspeakers of many Gaza mosques was unequivocal: "We send congratulations to the people and to Hamas, who tonight killed seven Israeli soldiers in Jabaliya. Give thanks to God for this successful operation, which destroyed an Israeli tank, killing all the soldiers inside." (...)

The Independent
This gaffe shows that Mr Bush is vulnerable after all

Donald Rumsfeld’s admission that there is no "hard evidence" that Saddam Hussein’s regime was in league with al-Qa’ida, will have surprised no one who took the trouble to read the report produced by the US 9/11 commission in July. The commission concluded that there was no operational link between the Iraqi president and Osama bin Laden, despite the Bush administration’s repeated insinuations to that effect. Mr Rumsfeld’s hasty efforts to backtrack, by citing past CIA reports positing a Saddam-Bin Laden link, hardly convinced. (...)

The Guardian
Petrol sniffers and macadamia nuts grab the headlines from Canberra’s slugfest
by Simon Tisdall

World briefing

Generally speaking, only Australians are interested in Australian elections - and not of all them, at that. More so when, as is the case now, the incumbent prime minister, John Howard, looks likely to edge a fourth consecutive term. (...) [page 16 | International]

The Independent
Israel backtracks in dispute with UN
by Donald Macintyre

The Israeli army backtracked last night on its claim that video footage from an unmanned drone had demonstrated that a UN ambulance in Gaza had been used to transport Qassam rockets of the sort that killed two Israeli children last week. (...)

The Independent
Afghanistan hits fever pitch as warlords turn ’democrat’
From the thriving centre of Kabul to remote mountain villages, Afghans go to the polls on Saturday still under the shadow of the old regimes. Report by Justin Huggler
by Justin Huggler

Samir Khan is a disappointed man. Three years ago he was one of the Northern Alliance soldiers who marched down the dusty road to Kabul as the Taliban fled, and was welcomed with wild scenes of jubilation that were watched the world over. Al-Qa’ida and its Taliban allies were in retreat, and Afghanistan was the centre of global attention. (...)

The Guardian
Afghans try to curb drug trade
by Ewen MacAskill

in Kabul

The Afghan government, supported by the US and UK, is to mount an all-out push over the next six months against officials and warlords involved in the drug trade, according to Afghan and western officials involved in counter-narcotics.

It will pit the Afghan government, supported by the US and other Nato forces, against the private armies of warlords who still control much of the country. (...) [page 17 | International]

The Guardian
Israel backtracks on claim that UN ambulance carried missile
by Chris McGreal

The Israeli army began backtracking yesterday on its claim that the UN had permitted one of its ambulances in Gaza to be used by Hamas to transport a missile.

Under Israeli pressure on Monday, the UN secretary general, Kofi Annan, said he would send a four-person team to investigate Israeli claims that video footage from a drone showed a man loading a "Qassam rocket", of the kind type fired into Israeli towns, into an ambulance. (...) [page 17 | International]

The Guardian
Girls shot as they baked and swept
Palestinian teenagers among growing number of children hit by Israeli snipers during ’Days of Penitence’
by Chris McGreal

in Jabaliya refugee camp

Islam Dwidar’s classmates were still taking in her shocking death - the teacher weeping outside before facing the girls, her closest friend recounting how they walked to school together each day - when the news arrived about Tahreer Abu El Jidyan. (...) [page 17 | International]

The Independent
Take them out, dude: pilots toast hit on Iraqi ’civilians’
by Andrew Buncombe

The Pentagon said yesterday it was investigating cockpit video footage that shows American pilots attacking and killing a group of apparently unarmed Iraqi civilians. (...)

The Guardian
Bigley given Irish passport in move to sway captors
by Brian Whitaker, Ewen MacAskill, Jamie Wilson, Rory McCarthy

The Irish government issued a passport to Iraq hostage Ken Bigley in the hope that the country’s long history of conflict with Britain might sway those holding him.

The government planned to scan a copy of the passport for screening on the Arab television network al-Jazeera last night.

Mr Bigley went to Iraq on a British passport but is entitled to Irish citizenship because his mother, Elizabeth, was born in Ireland. (...) [page 2 | News]

The Guardian
Blair seeks pledge from Sudan
PM gambles on talks with Bashir to ease refugees’ plight
by Patrick Wintour

Tony Blair will today fly to the Sudan to warn the Khartoum government that it must act swiftly to end the atrocities and refugee crisis in its western region of Darfur, mainly by allowing as many as 5,000 African Union peacekeeping troops free movement into the region this month. (...) [page 2 | News]

The Guardian
Bush allies admit war blunders
Bremer: too few troops Rumsfeld: no al-Qaida link
by Suzanne Goldenberg

America’s former proconsul in Baghdad delivered a damning critique of the Bush administration’s policy on Iraq yesterday, saying the US had made two grave errors of judgment in the early days of the war.

Paul Bremer, who was America’s most senior official in Baghdad until the handover last June, said the US committed two major blunders which compromised the course of events in Iraq: it went to war without enough troops and it did not contain the looting and violence after Saddam Hussein’s regime fell. (...) [page 1 | News]